Why Assigning Positive Intent Helps Reduce Power Struggles With Kids
“When you learn to attribute positive intent to other people, you possess a powerful skill. It is the skill you need to transform opposition into cooperation.”
— Becky Bailey
We all do it—often without realizing it.
We look at our child’s behavior and quietly (or not so quietly) label it as manipulative, selfish, rude, or irresponsible. However, assigning negative motives to children’s behavior often increases frustration and power struggles.
By contrast, assigning positive intent helps parents respond with more empathy, clarity, and effectiveness. Instead of assuming children are trying to be difficult, we begin looking at the unmet need, missing skill, or emotional struggle underneath the behavior.
And that shift can completely change the parent-child dynamic.
What Is Assigning Positive Intent?
Assigning positive intent means choosing to believe that your child’s behavior makes sense from their perspective—even when the behavior itself needs correction.
This does not mean approving of inappropriate behavior. Instead, it means separating the child from the behavior and responding with guidance rather than shame.
For example:
- What looks like manipulation is often a child trying to get a need met.
- What looks like selfishness may be a child who has not yet learned perspective-taking.
- What looks like rudeness is often a lack of social skills rather than disrespect.
- What looks like irresponsibility may simply be confusion about expectations.
Sometimes children are also tired, overwhelmed, hungry, frustrated, or emotionally dysregulated.
When parents assume bad intentions, children often become defensive. As a result, power struggles grow quickly.
However, when parents assign positive intent, children are more likely to stay open, connected, and cooperative.
Why Assigning Positive Intent Reduces Power Struggles
Children naturally become defensive when they feel judged or misunderstood. Therefore, criticism often leads to arguing, shutting down, or emotional escalation.
On the other hand, assigning positive intent communicates something powerful:
“I believe you are good, even when your behavior is not okay.”
That message builds trust and emotional safety.
According to Child Mind Institute, children respond best when adults focus on teaching skills instead of labeling behavior. Similarly, The American Academy of Pediatrics emphasizes calm, connected parenting approaches that support emotional regulation and cooperation.
Real-Life Parenting Examples of Assigning Positive Intent
Instead of Assigning a Negative Motive
Instead of saying:
“You can’t just walk away from the table. That’s rude and irresponsible.”
Try saying:
“You thought it was okay to leave the table and that I’d call you when it was time to help. Next time, I’d like you to ask to be excused before you leave.”
In this example, the parent still sets a limit. However, the child does not feel attacked or shamed.
Instead of Accusing
Instead of saying:
“You always cry when you don’t get your way. That’s selfish.”
Try saying:
“You’re really disappointed you can’t come with me. It feels so sad that it comes out as tears. Next time you can say, ‘Mommy, it makes me sad when I have to stay with the babysitter.’”
As a result, the child learns emotional awareness and communication skills rather than becoming defensive.
Assigning Positive Intent Builds Emotional Connection
One of the biggest benefits of assigning positive intent is that it strengthens connection between parents and children.
When children feel understood, they are far more willing to cooperate.
Additionally, this parenting approach helps children:
- Feel emotionally safe
- Learn appropriate behavior without shame
- Develop emotional regulation skills
- Improve communication
- Reduce defensiveness
Most importantly, children begin to internalize the belief that mistakes do not make them “bad.”
Positive Intent Does Not Mean Permissive Parenting
Some parents worry that assigning positive intent means letting children avoid responsibility. However, that is not the case.
Children still need boundaries, expectations, and accountability.
The difference is in how the parent responds.
Instead of reacting with blame or criticism, the parent stays calm, teaches the missing skill, and maintains connection while setting limits.
That balance is what helps children grow.
Final Thoughts on Assigning Positive Intent
Assigning positive intent does not mean ignoring difficult behavior. Instead, it means choosing curiosity over accusation.
When parents stop assuming the worst, children often stop defending themselves quite so fiercely.
And when children feel understood, cooperation becomes much easier.
Sometimes the fastest way to change behavior is to first change the story we tell ourselves about why the behavior is happening.
You can learn more in my book, Parenting Simply: Preparing Kids for Life, filled with practical parenting tools you can use right away.
Or, if you are looking for step-by-step guidance to become a calmer, more confident parent, check out my online course, Simple Ways to Parent Without Anger.
Did you hear? I have a new podcast! Simply Jewish Parenting. Subscribe here!
Want to learn more? Read:
👉What to Say Instead of “Good Job” (And Why It Matters)